The Princeton athletic department was nice enough to generate and send over plus/minus numbers on each of the Tigers for the 2011-12 non-conference slate.
This initial chart shows the number of minutes played across the first 16 games this season and the difference in points scored by Princeton while each player was on the floor versus points allowed by the Tigers during the same span.
I've also broken down +/- per 40 minutes for all current rotation players, pulled +/- for DI opponents only and added Net/40 numbers ("Roland Rate") with inspiration from Hoya Prospectus.
Here's the data for the complete roster:
Player Minutes +/- Davis 531:33 +68 Bray 522:58 +66 Koon 231:08 +59 Darrow 360:11 +58 Hummer 537:53 +52 Saunders 341:28 +5 Hazel 97:06 -2 Wilson 15:59 -7 Fabrizius 2:32 -8 Comfort 76:02 -11 Edwards 7:03 -11 Garbade 8:15 -13 Connolly 286:07 -14 Clement 16:24 -16 Barrett 142:47 -18 Sherburne 87:45 -20
Princeton has scored 1029 points to date, allowing 987 points.
As for individual single game highs and lows, Mack Darrow was +31 at Northeastern. Brendan Connolly was -22 in the same game.
The most successful lineup combination? Still the group who has played the most together:
T.J. Bray, Douglas Davis, Ian Hummer, Mack Darrow and Patrick Saunders, who are +28 in 123:34 of play.
The least successful five? Now the fifth-most used lineup and the initial 2011-12 starting lineup:
Bray, Davis, Will Barrett, Hummer and Brendan Connolly, combining to go -12 in 30:51.
Subtracting the two DIII games, +/- adjusts as follows:
Player Minutes +/- Koon 196:31 +55 Bray 470:45 +33 Davis 484:26 +30 Darrow 316:42 +20 Hummer 502:24 +11 Barrett 124:51 -7 Connolly 256:30 -24 Sherburne 73:58 -25 Saunders 307:00 -31
Plus/minus divided by 40 minutes for the regular nine player rotation:
Koon +10.21
Darrow +6.44
Davis +5.12
Bray +5.05
Hummer +3.87
Saunders +0.59
Connolly -1.96
Barrett -5.04
Sherburne -9.12
Net/40 (“Roland Rate”) numbers:
Davis +13.2
Bray +12.1
Koon +11.8
Darrow +8.6
Hummer +7.1
Saunders -4.1
Connolly -7.9
Barrett -9.7
Sherburne -13.5
Net/40 (“Roland Rate”) numbers (DI opponents only):
Bray +12.3
Davis +12.1
Koon +11.8
Darrow +8.6
Hummer +2.9
Barrett -3.5
Connolly -7.3
Saunders -9.6
Sherburne -16.0
If you want to compare these numbers versus 10 games in, you can do so here. The biggest increase is Davis' +40.